For many aspiring student-athletes, choosing the right college and athletic division is a crucial decision that shapes both their academic and their athletic years. Every year we see student-athletes transfer after their first season because of location, academics or limited playing time. Most of that can be avoided by doing your due diligence up front. Below we walk through the considerations that help you find the right college and the right division to play in.
Athletic level and goals
The level you compete at and your athletic ambitions should be the foundation of your decision. Set long-term goals: do you want to play professionally, become a coach, or simply keep competing at a high level alongside your degree? Then be realistic about whether your level matches the starters of the team you have in mind.
Ultimately, college only serves your athletic development if you are actually competing. A seat on the bench at a top programme will do less for you than a starting spot one division down.
Which division fits you?
The NCAA, the NAIA and the NJCAA each have their own characteristics and rules. NCAA Division I is the best known because it gets the most media coverage, but it is the right fit for very few student-athletes. Division II, the NAIA and the NJCAA often offer a better balance of playing time, academics and support.
So choose the division that aligns with your skill level and your priorities, not the one with the biggest name.
Academic fit
Do not forget that you are a student-athlete: student comes first. Check whether the programme and the quality of education match your goals. Pay attention to the academic support and the flexibility athletes are given — think tutoring, study hall and the room to reschedule exams around games.
Coaching and facilities
The quality of coaching and athletic facilities has a major impact on your development. Research the coaching staff, their credentials and their coaching philosophy. Look into the practice fields, weight rooms and medical support available to athletes. A conversation with the coach is your moment to ask about all of this.
Team culture and dynamics
Joining a college team means becoming part of a close-knit community. Pay attention to the team’s culture, its internal dynamics and its work ethic. Talk to current athletes and to the coach to get a sense of the values and goals, and be honest with yourself about whether you fit that dynamic.
Geographic location
Location matters more to some people than to others. Think about the climate, the distance to a big city and what there is to do in the area. Your housing situation on campus and the college life around it also shape how you will feel there for four years.
Finances
For most student-athletes, cost is a decisive factor. Map out the cost of attendance and which athletic scholarships and other financial aid packages a university can offer. Keep in mind that a full ride is the exception rather than the rule. Choose a university with a manageable financial package, so you can pursue your athletic and academic goals without undue financial stress.
Big or small university?
Beyond division and location, the size of the university plays a part. Large universities offer extensive facilities and more scholarships; small universities offer more personal attention and a tighter team. Our article on a big or small university puts both options side by side.
Take your time with this decision
Finding the right college and division looks different for everyone. Every year we see student-athletes transfer after their first year because of location, academics or limited playing time. In most cases that can be avoided by doing your due diligence during the recruitment process.
Take the time to compare colleges, seek guidance from coaches and mentors, and trust your instincts on this one. Want to talk through your own situation? Send us a message.